Une citation de Lightfoot

Le Forum Catholique

Imprimer le Fil Complet

Jean Ferrand -  2014-01-17 10:41:23

Une citation de Lightfoot

Une citation de Lightfoot : (extrait de la page proposée par Meneau)


How can we explain the fact, that throughout the enormous mass of talmudical and early rabbinical literature this sect is not once mentioned by name, and that even the supposed allusions to them, which have been discovered for the first time in the present century, turn out on investigation to be hypothetical and illusory? The difficulty is much greater in this latter instance; but the answer is the same in both cases. The silence is explained by the comparative insignificance of the sect, their small numbers and their retired habits. Their settlements were far removed from the great centers of political and religious life. Their recluse habits, as a rule, prevented them from interfering in the common business of the world. Philo and Josephus have given prominence to them, because their ascetic practices invested them with the character of philosophers and interested the Greeks and Romans in their history; but in the national life of the Jews they bore a very insignificant part.* If the Sadducees, who held the highest offices in the hierarchy, are only mentioned directly on three occasions in the Gospels,** it can be no surprise that the Essenes are not named at all.



Lightfoot était un évêque anglican du XIXe siècle, qui n'a donc pas connu les découvertes de Qumrân et autres. Mais il reste très érudit surtout dans le domaine talmudique. Sa réflexion semble répondre pertinemment à votre interrogation.

Quant à l'épître à Barnabé, elle figure certes dans le Codex sinaïticus à la suite de l'Apocalypse, mais cela ne suffit pas pour dire qu'elle a été canonique. Le canon, au fait, qu'est-ce que c'est ? C'est une décision d’Église qui remonte à saint Athanase d'Alexandrie et à saint Damase (pour le Nouveau Testament).
http://www.leforumcatholique.org/message.php?num=742145